Evolution Metals (NASDAQ: EMAT): A Cesspool of Fraud. A $2M Payoff, Convicted Felons, Insider Trading, Market Manipulation, and no Material Operations
Multiple whistleblowers provided Capybara with evidence of serious wrongdoing at Evolution Metals, including securities fraud, insider trading, stock manipulation, and a scheme to pay $2M to silence a whistleblower. The evidence includes bank records, internal documents, and recordings of executives discussing criminal activities.

Initial Disclosure: Affiliates of Capybara Research take market positions in the companies we report on and our investigative journalism is funded by the trading profits of these affiliates. This report is not financial advice. Do your own due diligence. Please read our full disclaimer at the bottom of this report.
If you have information that you'd like to share, we encourage you to contact us.
We protect our sources, and anonymize identities where necessary.
As investigative journalists, we have an ethical duty to protect the identities of our sources, particularly when a source is at risk of harm or retaliation. To that end, we anonymize sources where necessary. This may include using partial names, aliases, generic job titles, or broad identifiers such as "former executive", "former insider", or "industry expert".
Key Findings
Evolution Metals (EM) markets itself as a “critical materials” company that recycles electronic waste to extract valuable metals. The company went public in January 2026 by merging with an OTC-listed SPAC. After the merger, the company immediately uplisted to Nasdaq. With the closing of the merger, the SPAC provided the company with a meager $1.6M in capital. However, in the two years preceding the merger, EM lent the SPAC $1.5M, of which $1.16M was written off by the end of 2025.
The company’s operations are composed entirely of four tiny money-losing Korean subsidiaries acquired as part of the SPAC merger. In 2025, their total revenue was $6.4M, tangible assets were $8.6M, and all four had going concern warnings. Most damning, two of the Korean companies, accounting for 92% of revenue, were reportedly written off by their majority owner in 2024. Reports in the South Korean press noted concerns that the companies were used in “money games” “for the benefit of specific forces”. While the Korean companies appear to have little economic value, Evolution Metals paid a total of $78.9M to acquire them, with 61% of the price paid in cash to undisclosed dissenting shareholders. According to SEC filings, the company intends to raise the cash through the sale of EMAT shares on the open market. [1] [2] [3] [4]
- A whistleblower provided Capybara with recordings of company executives conspiring to pay $2M to silence a potential whistleblower. One senior executive can be heard asking “what do we need to do, right, to shut him the fuck up? If we pay him two million dollars does that make it go away?” After some back and forth, executives can be heard agreeing to make the payoff and then planning how to carry it out.
- Whistleblower recordings include statements indicating that the payoff was intended to cover up wrongdoing related to an $82M loan and the company’s Korean subsidiaries, where all of the company’s operations are located. An executive explained the seriousness of the situation, saying "[…] how we manage this because the eighty-two million dollars, if they blow the fucking whistle, goes to the fake Korea, and it, it opens up Pandora’s box."
- In whistleblower recordings, executives can be heard discussing how to conceal the payoff from auditors and investors. One executive asked “I gotta figure out how we do this in the disclosures for the auditors, because everybody’s gonna fucking see it. Do you know how to do that?” Another responded “I think two million could, would be considered immaterial. Right? Probably. At least since that would avoid any kind of 8-K trigger.” They then go on to discuss other SEC filings, whether they will include compromising financial details, and if they can be disguised as “an internal loan […] for general corporate purposes”.
- The company’s head of investor relations and “Advisor to the Chairman”, Robert Coberly, is a convicted felon who pled guilty to running multiple Ponzi schemes. According to court filings, the Ponzi schemes resulted in investors losing tens of millions of dollars. Coberly’s LinkedIn profile lists Evolution Metals as his current employer and describes himself as “Investor Relations and Advisor to Chairman”. In what appears to be a ham-handed attempt to conceal his involvement, Coberly is not listed on the company’s leadership page, his name is not mentioned in SEC filings, and his company stock appears to be held through a Wyoming shell company with nominee directors.
- Evidence provided by whistleblowers indicates that insiders and an undisclosed 10% shareholder have been involved in a scheme to manipulate the share price of EMAT. One executive stated that the stock will be managed by “Steve”, who, the evidence suggests, is Stephen Reeder, a convicted felon who we believe controlled 30% of the company’s stock at the time of the SPAC merger.
- Whistleblower evidence indicates that a senior executive shared material non-public information with an associate and directed them to trade in the company’s stock. The evidence also implicates a close associate of an executive, who traded in EMAT at the time of the IPO, and later took out a mortgage to allegedly fund more stock transactions.
- Whistleblower documents show that the company’s largest source of funding has been Stephen Reeder, a convicted felon who was sentenced to 46 months in federal prison for bank fraud. Whistleblower documents and company records filed with various states link Reeder to shell companies that own approximately 30% of the company’s stock. In SEC filings, these shell companies are reported to be controlled by Reeder associates, including his employees and his spouse. Court records provide insight into Reeder’s checkered past, which includes real estate fraud, bank fraud, and connections to pump and dump schemes.
Reeder appears to exert significant influence over the company through close relationships with company insiders, including the founder and Chairman, the head of IR, and an “independent director” who’s actually employed by Reeder.
- According to two witnesses, founder and executive Chairman David Wilcox received envelopes of cash from Stephen Reeder, whom he called “Papa Steve”. When asked why Reeder gave him large sums of cash, Wilcox reportedly responded, “I guess he wants to make sure I have money.” Sources close to Wilcox claim they know of no legitimate reason for the cash payments and that Wilcox spent the cash on personal expenses.
- “Head of Investor Relations” Robert Coberly is a longtime associate of Reeder, going back to at least the late 1990s when they were sued for their involvement in an alleged fraud at Capitol Silver Mines Inc. Years later, after both Coberly and Reeder served time in prison, Reeder employed Coberly at his real estate company. Coberly’s now-wife also worked at Reeder’s real estate company, but under a different name.
- “Independent director” and chair of the audit committee, Thomas Stoddard, is the COO and CFO of Reeder’s real estate company. In fact, when Reeder invested in EMAT, Stoddard signed the investment contract on behalf of Reeder’s shell company.
- In SEC filings, Wilcox is reported to be the beneficial owner of the Zeus Trust, through which he has majority control over the company. The trust is even named after Wilcox’s dog, Zeus. However, whistleblower evidence indicates that Reeder is the beneficial owner of approximately 23.5M shares held by the Zeus Trust. This raises serious questions about Wilcox’s involvement in concealing Reeder’s ownership stake.
- Bank records show that Wilcox received tens of thousands of dollars in wire transfers from shell companies linked to Robert Coberly, the convicted felon in charge of investor relations. The records show payments were sent directly to Wilcox’s personal bank account and to an account belonging to a person close to Wilcox. According to that account owner, Wilcox had access to the funds and used them to pay personal expenses. This claim is substantiated by bank records and other documentation.
- According to sources close to the company, both the SEC and Nasdaq are investigating the company, and have reached out to former insiders to gather information. The sources indicate that the SEC is looking into possible securities violations and financial statement fraud, while Nasdaq is investigating whether the company made false statements and violated Nasdaq’s listing requirements.
- Evidence suggests that tens of millions of dollars could have been misappropriated in the acquisition of Korean subsidiaries. Specifically, the company recorded payments of $48M to “dissenting shareholders” in Korea. The shareholders haven’t been disclosed and SEC filings include conflicting statements about whether or not there even were dissenting shareholders. Recent filings indicate that the company issued free-trading shares stating “Company intends to liquidate such shares and use the proceeds to settle the obligation to dissenting shareholders”. Based on whistleblower evidence, we believe this could be a scheme by insiders to sell shares and secretly extract tens of millions of dollars from the company.
- Adding to suspicion around the Korean acquisitions, SEC filings indicate that Wilcox invested millions of dollars in “foreign direct investment for the benefit of EM”. At this time, there have been no disclosures about what investments were made or what the company got in return. The company did disclose that it wrote off $4M in “related party notes” which included loans made to Wilcox for foreign investments. We suspect the funds could have been invested in the Korean companies which EMAT later acquired. This could help explain the mysterious “dissenting shareholders” to whom the company owes $48M in cash.
- According to court records, company founder and Chairman David Wilcox has been arrested twice in the past two years, once for DUI and once for violating a protective order. Court records from Florida also show Wilcox as the defendant in a domestic violence case in 2022. The protective order and the domestic violence case involved different romantic partners. As a result of the DUI, Wilcox’s driver’s license is suspended, and he is prohibited from consuming drugs or alcohol. Despite these restrictions, we’ve seen evidence that Wilcox has continued to drink. These matters raise serious questions about Wilcox’s judgment and his ability to lead a public company.
- Three days after the SPAC merger, EMAT disclosed that Chris Hansen resigned as independent director, as well as Chair of the Compensation Committee and Chair of the Nominating and Corporate Governance Committee. Some filings state that he resigned on January 7 while others state he resigned on January 8. Email correspondence, seen by Capybara, shows that Hansen withdrew as a nominee director 6 months prior, in July 2025. Despite his resignation, the company continued to list him as a director nominee in SEC filings and named him as an active board member when the SPAC was completed in January 2026. One day prior to the SPAC merger, the company even submitted a power of attorney ostensibly signed by Hansen. The company then used the invalid power of attorney to submit false SEC filings in Hansen’s name.
- In August 2024, EM hired the well-respected law firm Jones Day “to assist with the de-SPAC process and related legal matters.” However, according to an email from Jones Day, they resigned as legal counsel for the company on December 13, 2025, just one month before the SPAC merger was completed. It’s unclear why Jones Day withdrew, but a former insider claims to have alerted the firm to serious wrongdoing at the company and that this led Jones Day to drop EM as a client.
- Whistleblower evidence indicates that company executives used encrypted burner email accounts for business communications and to share documents. The evidence also indicates that at least one executive used a burner phone to share incriminating information with another insider. The use of burner accounts and phones for business communication is highly unusual and raises serious concerns about the executives’ intentions and the possibility that they were trying to hide wrongdoing.
- According to SEC filings, the company’s Korean subsidiaries changed auditors three times in the past two years. In December 2024, Samil PricewaterhouseCoopers “declined to stand for re-election”. Grassi & Co and UHY then took over with each auditing two of the Korean subsidiaries. According to SEC filings, a mere three months after being appointed both Grassi and UHY resigned. Soon after, Ernst & Young Han Young was appointed as auditor.
- The same reputation management firm was hired to suppress negative internet search results about Reeder and Wilcox. The company created templated websites and fake online profiles for both insiders, and then used SEO techniques to get those sites ranked highly in search results for their names. This could partially explain why so many people were unaware of Reeder’s criminal past and Wilcox’s legal troubles. Contributing to the issue, Reeder and Wilcox use aliases rather than their legal names. Reeder goes by “C Steve Reeder” and Wilcox uses his middle and last name. We haven’t found an explanation for Reeder’s use of “C Steve Reeder”, since his full name contains not a single letter “C”. However, court records show that Reeder has a history of using aliases and fake identities to perpetrate his crimes. His supervised release even included specific conditions that he not use any “form of identification in any name, other than the defendant’s true legal name”. In his trial for bank fraud, the prosecutor even noted that Reeder was found in possession of a false ID in the name “Mark Ellington Roser”.
$2M Payoff to Cover Up Wrongdoing
Evidence provided by a whistleblower indicates that the executive team of Evolution Metals conspired to pay $2M to silence a potential whistleblower and prevent them from exposing wrongdoing at the company. The evidence includes audio recordings purportedly of executives planning the payoff and how to conceal it from auditors and investors. Based upon extensive analysis of the recordings, we believe they are authentic.
To protect the source, we can’t share the original recording, but we can share excerpts of the transcript.
The conversation took place in January 2026 and the transcript excerpts include the following participants:
- David Wilcox: Founder, Chairman, and largest shareholder
- Frank Moon: CEO
- Christopher Clower: CFO of EMAT and principal of Welsbach, the SPAC that merged with Evolution Metals
David Wilcox: “Um, so, I wanted to download this Frank, for, to make sure we’re postured the right way. The, the payment to Jung, through [unclear] explained at very short level to John, is, you know, okay call the eighty-two million dollar thing, if the other lenders find out. Um obviously, Anthony who’s not on the call, we’re in a closed circle, right.. what happened and what’s your posturing ability of being able to do this and what do you think, right, to stop Jung from blowing the whistle?”
Frank Moon: “Well, I guess, you know, he’s actually in a desperate situation, either way right.”
[…]
David Wilcox: “…you know, how we manage this because the eighty-two million dollars, if they blow the fucking whistle, goes to the fake Korea, and it, it opens up Pandora’s box. Which is what I’m trying to avoid, that we know. And, I’ve got John here with me. Like what, what do we, it would be an open book, what do we need to do, right, to shut him the fuck up? If we pay him two million dollars does that make it go away?”
After some back and forth, executives can be heard discussing how to conceal the payment from auditors and investors:
David Wilcox: “Okay, so, can you prepare, or have Anthony, without John being involved, prepare the paperwork, right, with a nondisclosure and then I gotta figure out, hey Chris, I gotta figure out how we do this in the disclosures for the auditors, because everybody’s gonna fucking see it. Do you know how to do that?”
Chris Clower: “Clower: Yeah. Um, I think, I think two million could, would be considered immaterial. Right? Probably. At least since that would avoid any kind of 8-K trigger.”
They then go on to discuss disguising financial dealings as an “internal loan for general corporate purposes”.
Convicted Felon, Stephen Reeder was the Largest Investor and 30% Shareholder
Documents provided by whistleblowers show that the company’s largest source of funding has been Stephen Reeder, a convicted felon whom prosecutors described as a career criminal implicated in fraudulent schemes spanning decades, including bank fraud, real estate fraud, and stock manipulation. Whistleblower documents and company records filed with various states suggest that Reeder could control approximately 30% of the company’s stock. In SEC filings, shell companies linked to Reeder are reported to be controlled by Reeder associates, including his employees and his spouse. Court records provide insight into Reeder’s checkered past, which includes real estate fraud, bank fraud, and connections to pump and dump schemes.
Whistleblower documents show that Reeder was the largest investor in the company, contributing $50M for working capital and showing interest in an additional $100M PIPE investment.
Image from a Document about EM’s Project Zeus
Note that under “Investor/Fund Name” it says “UCR Group”, which is Reeder’s private real estate company.
When the company put together a guest list for a Nasdaq event, Reeder was listed first among seed investors, as “Steve”:
Company Guest List for Nasdaq Event, “EMAT Nasdaq Event Guest List v2.xlsx”
Notably absent from the investor list are the shell companies that now claim to own large stakes in the company. Later we’ll see how those shell companies link back to Reeder.
Reeder Has Been Actively Involved in the Company Since at Least 2024
While his name appears in no SEC filings and he isn’t a shareholder of record, evidence shows that Reeder has been actively involved in the company for years.
In August 2024, Evolution Metals hosted a site visit in Missouri. Attendees were provided an itinerary for the event that listed Reeder as an “EM&T Limited Partner” along with his wife Nicole Garcia and his associate Tom Stoddard.
Itinerary for Missouri site visit in August 2024, “St Louis Aug4-7 13v31July (Final PDF).pdf”
Reeder associate Bob Coberly also attended the site visit as EM&T’s “Head of Investor Relations”.
Participants were provided another document with information on all attendees, including biographies, and arrival and departure times. That document shows identical arrival and departure times for Reeder, Stoddard, and Garcia. This indicates that they were on the same flights and likely traveling together. Further tying them together, each is listed along with their official title at UCR Group, Reeder’s company that allegedly invested $50M into Evolution Metals.
Itinerary for Missouri site visit in August 2024, “EM&T Missouri Trip Arrival and Departures - 6V31Jul24.pdf”
Later we’ll see that Garcia appears to control a shell company that owns 96.8M shares of EMAT. We’ll also see that Stoddard was involved in Reeder’s investments in EMAT and later became an EMAT “independent director” and chair of the audit committee.
Reeder also joined the executive team on an official trip to Korea, where they met with the Korean companies that were later acquired as part of the SPAC merger:

Executive site visit to KMMI Inc in Korea
Documents produced by EM&T show that Reeder was the largest investor and that he was actively involved in important company events. The documents also show that Stoddard and Garcia were involved in the company through their relationship with Reeder.
Springrock Management Owns 96.8M Shares and is Linked to Reeder and His Wife
There’s substantial evidence linking Reeder to Springrock Management Inc, an EMAT shareholder that owns 96.8M shares according to SEC filings. Evidence includes filings with the state of Nevada, disclosures in SEC filings, and whistleblower documents.
Springrock’s officers include Reeder’s wife Nicole Garcia, his employees Bolivar Rodriguez and Thomas Stoddard, and his longtime associate James Slayton:
Nevada SilverFlume Business Portal
Most notably, “S Reeder” is listed as a former director of Springrock:
Nevada SilverFlume Business Portal
Sources close to Reeder confirm that he and Garcia are married. The two also have multiple residential addresses in common, and using OSINT Industries, we found Garcia’s Airbnb profile picture, showing the two embracing and Garcia wearing an engagement ring:

The website for Reeder’s real estate company, UCR Group, lists Garcia, Rodriguez, and Stoddard as employees. Archived versions of the website show that Stoddard and Rodriguez have worked for UCR Group since at least 2018.

Another director of Springrock, James Slayton, is also longtime associate of Reeder going back to at least 1995 when they were both officers of Golden Seeds Game Co:
The registered address of Springrock is a residential duplex in Las Vegas. Property records show that the property is owned by James Slayton.
Google Maps Street View of 201 N Bruce St, Las Vegas, NV, 89101, USA
Slayton is a former CPA. Professional misconduct resulted in his CPA license being revoked in Ohio and he surrendered his license in Nevada in lieu of disciplinary action. Slayton was also barred from practicing as an accountant before the SEC because of his connections to two separate frauds, California Software Corporation and Freedom Surf Inc.. Reeder and Coberly were also connected to Freedom Surf and both were named as defendants in a lawsuit alleging fraud at the company.

Good Earth 1000, LLC Owned 63.4M Shares and is Linked to Reeder and His Wife
In SEC filings, Reeder’s wife Nicole Garcia is listed as the manager of Good Earth 1000:
EMAT 2025 10-K, filed 2026-02-20
Filings with the Nevada Secretary of State show that Stephen Reeder was the registered manager until September 2025, at which time his wife Nicole Garcia took over as manager:
Nevada SilverFlume Business Portal
Besides being Reeder’s wife and employee, Garcia is the registered manager for other Reeder companies unrelated to Evolution Metals.
Zeus Trust Holds 23.5M Shares for Reeder According to Whistleblower Evidence
In SEC filings, Wilcox claims to be the beneficial owner of 416 million shares through the Zeus Trust, which is named after one of his dogs:
EMAT 2025 10-K, filed 2026-02-20
However, whistleblower evidence indicates that the Zeus Trust is holding approximately 23.5M shares for Reeder. To protect sources, the evidence can’t be shared publicly at this time.
Quartz Investment Group - Circumstantial Evidence Linking it to Reeder
Quartz Investment Group LLC is an EMAT shareholder and circumstantial evidence links it to Reeder.
Quartz was formed in the same state, on the same day, and by the same law firm as Springrock Management, an entity with strong ties to Reeder.
In the case of Quartz, the true owner is better concealed. The company was originally managed by an attorney who appears to be a nominee representing the actual owner. In 2025, the manager was changed to a company called “5 GEM PARTNERS”:
Nevada SilverFlume Business Portal
Despite extensive searching, we were unable to find a company with that name.
However, there is a Wyoming company named 5 GEM Investments, LLC that was formed by a member of the same law firm that created Quartz and Springrock. 5 GEM Investments was formed one day before “5 GEM PARTNERS” became manager of Quartz. The ultimate owner of the company is hidden behind nominee directors.
Stephen Reeder: Convicted Felon Depicted as a Career Criminal in Court Records
Felony Conviction - Bank Fraud
In 2005, Reeder was convicted of bank fraud and sentenced to 46 months in federal prison and 5 years of supervised release:
USA v. Reeder, et al, Docket No. 8:01-cr-00135 (C.D. Cal. Aug 15, 2001), Document 277
Specifically, Reeder was found guilty of fraudulently obtaining bank loans, taking the loan proceeds, and then defaulting on the loans:
USA v. Reeder, et al, Docket No. 8:01-cr-00135 (C.D. Cal. Aug 15, 2001), Document 274
The US Bureau of Prisons Inmate Locator confirms that Reeder served his sentence and was released in July 2009:
US Bureau of Prisons Inmate Locator
For more details on Reeder’s crime, see the Grand Jury Indictment.
Court Filings Depict Reeder as a Career Criminal
In sentencing, the prosecution argued that Reeder “devised and led the scheme” to defraud banks:
USA v. Reeder, et al, Docket No. 8:01-cr-00135 (C.D. Cal. Aug 15, 2001), Document 219
The prosecution also stated that Reeder engaged in “fraudulent schemes” for a decade and the schemes to defraud “extended far beyond the three federally insured financial institutions charged in the indictment.”
USA v. Reeder, et al, Docket No. 8:01-cr-00135 (C.D. Cal. Aug 15, 2001), Document 219
The prosecution also cites Reeder’s “involvement in a fraudulent scheme to manipulate the stock of Capitol Silver Mines”:
USA v. Reeder, et al, Docket No. 8:01-cr-00135 (C.D. Cal. Aug 15, 2001), Document 219
Reeder filed appeals with various courts, including the District Court, the Circuit Court of Appeals, and the US Supreme Court. All of Reeder’s appeals were denied.
Reeder’s Use of False Identities
Reeder has a history of using false identities and aliases as evidenced in court filings and his current use of the alias “C Steve Reeder”. It’s unclear where the “C” came from, since his full name “Stephen William Reeder” doesn’t contain a single “C”. People previously involved in Evolution Metals claim that this simple name change was effective at hiding his criminal past from business associates.
When Reeder appealed his conviction for bank fraud, the court cited “Reeder’s use of a false name when dealing with a lender”:
United States v. Reeder, No. 05-50866., 2007 BL 3119 (9th Cir. May 17, 2007)
During Reeder’s sentencing for bank fraud, the prosecution noted that Reeder was found to have a “false California driver’s license” under the name “Mark Ellington Roser”:
USA v. Reeder, et al, Docket No. 8:01-cr-00135 (C.D. Cal. Aug 15, 2001), Document 219
Because Reeder used aliases and fake identities to perpetrate his frauds, his supervised release included special conditions that he not use any “form of identification in any name, other than the defendant’s true legal name”. For the duration of his supervised release, Reeder was also prohibited from engaging in business related to real estate sales or mortgage loans.
USA v. Reeder, et al, Docket No. 8:01-cr-00135 (C.D. Cal. Aug 15, 2001), Document 220
Reeder’s use of the alias “C. Steve Reeder” can be seen in various online profiles and accounts, including:
Adding to the intrigue, Reeder doesn’t use an alias for services that are commonly thought of as private. For example, he used his real name on Fitbit and Dropbox, and to register various internet domain names.
Reeder Filed for Bankruptcy in 2010
Reeder’s 5-year supervised release ended in November 2010. One month later, Reeder filed for personal bankruptcy in the Central District of California. The bankruptcy case was closed in April 2011 with Reeder’s debts being discharged.
Stephen William Reeder, 1:10-bk-26073, (Bankr. C.D. Cal.)
Despite his bankruptcy, whistleblower documents show that Reeder invested at least $50M into Evolution Metals and we estimate his current stake is worth over $1.5 billion.
Founder & Chairman Wilcox Received Wire Transfers from Shell Companies Linked to Coberly, a Convicted Felon and Longtime Associate of Reeder
Bank records shared with Capybara, show that Wilcox received tens of thousands of dollars in wire transfers from shell companies linked to Coberly. As we’ve shown, Coberly is a close associate of Reeder and their ties going back to at least the late 1990s.
Along with transfers sent directly to Wilcox’s bank account, payments were also made to a close associate of Wilcox. The account owner claims that Wilcox had access to the account and used the funds to pay personal expenses.
A sample of the wire transfers is provided below:

Bank records and additional documentation corroborate that the funds were used for personal expenses, including payments to personal credit cards. The statements also show that thousands of dollars were withdrawn from ATMs.
One source of the wire transfers was Crown Nil LLC. According to Texas state filings, Crown Nil was created in 2022 by Coberly’s son Jayke. A subsequent filing with the state of Texas lists Robert Coberly as a manager and Robert’s wife Summer signed the document.

The other source of wire transfers was Renergy USA REE LLC. According to filings with the state of Texas, Renergy was created by the Coberlys in 2022, with Summer Coberly named as manager and she also signed the document.

Links Between Coberly Shell Companies and Reeder
There’s also evidence suggesting a link between the shell companies and Reeder. Coberly’s profile on ContactOut states that starting in 2017, he worked for Reeder’s UCR Group through ACS Consulting:
https://contactout.com/Bob-Coberly-376731407
Company filings with the state of Texas show that ACS Consulting was the registered agent of Renergy and the organizer of Crown Nil.
Adding to the intrigue, the two Coberly companies were created around the same time that UCR Group executed a Deed of Trust with Thornwood Properties. The deed was for a residential property on Thornwood Drive and was the same address used on company filings by ACS Consulting, Crown Nil, and Renergy. The deed of trust was signed in October 2022, 43 days after the formation of Crown Nil, and 34 days before the formation of Renergy.
Summer Coberly signed the deed as “Manager of Thornwood Properties” and also on her own behalf, as a party to the contract. This suggests that she had a personal stake in the property.
Coming full circle, documents filed with the SEC show that Thornwood Properties owned equity in Evolution Metals before the SPAC merger.
Robert Coberly: Convicted Of Running a Ponzi Scheme & Head of Investor Relations
Coberly is a central figure at Evolution Metals, serving as head of investor relations and advisor to the chairman. However, he’s not included on the company’s leadership page, and his name appears in none of the company’s SEC filings.
Coberly’s LinkedIn profile indicates that he works at Evolution Metals as “Investor Relations and Advisor to the Chairman”:
LinkedIn profile of Robert Coberly
LinkedIn profile of Robert Coberly
The company also described Coberly as the “Head of Investor Relations”. For example, an itinerary provided to attendees of a company site visit in 2024:
Itinerary for Missouri site visit in August 2024 “St Louis Aug4-7 13v31July (Final PDF).pdf”
Another company document, shared by a whistleblower, describes Coberly as the “Head of Capital Investing” and shows his official company email address:
Company Guest List for Nasdaq Event, “EMAT Nasdaq Event Guest List v2.xlsx”
As further evidence of Coberly’s central role at the company, in 2024, the company’s website included a button with the text “Contact Bob Coberly to Learn More”. Clicking the button would email Coberly directly at his company email address:
evolutionmetalsandtechnologies.com, archived 2024-05-20
Despite his central role at the company, Coberly’s name doesn’t appear in a single SEC filing or on the company’s current website. This may have been a deliberate choice given Coberly’s criminal background, his previous financial frauds, and his ties to pump and dump schemes.
Criminal Background - Convicted of Running Multi-Million Dollar Ponzi Schemes
In 2008, Coberly pleaded guilty in federal court to running multiple Ponzi schemes that defrauded investors out of tens of millions of dollars. Coberly and his co-conspirator stole millions of dollars from investors and used the money to fund their lavish lifestyles, including mansions and luxury cars. Coberly and his partner were both sentenced to federal prison.
Ponzi Scheme #1 - $6.7M
As part of Coberly’s guilty plea, he admitted to running multiple Ponzi schemes where he and his co-conspirator stole millions of dollars and used it to fund their lavish lifestyles.
USA v. Somoza et al, Docket No. 2:06-cr-00479 (C.D. Cal. Jun 13, 2006), Document 185 Exhibit 2
Caught by the SEC
After an SEC investigation, Coberly and his co-conspirator settled with the SEC and agreed to return investors’ money.
https://www.sec.gov/enforcement-litigation/litigation-releases/lr-19321
USA v. Somoza et al, Docket No. 2:06-cr-00479 (C.D. Cal. Jun 13, 2006), Document 185 Exhibit 2
Defrauded Wealthy Investor to Pay Back Previous Victims
In court filings, Coberly admitted that he and his co-conspirator raised millions of dollars from a new wealthy investor and used it to pay off victims of their first Ponzi scheme. According to court filings, they told investors the money was from their original investments.
USA v. Somoza et al, Docket No. 2:06-cr-00479 (C.D. Cal. Jun 13, 2006), Document 185 Exhibit 2
Ponzi Scheme #2 - $64.6M
According to Coberly, he and his associate then ran another $64.6M Ponzi scheme and used the funds to pay back their previous victims and continue to fund their lavish lifestyles:
USA v. Somoza et al, Docket No. 2:06-cr-00479 (C.D. Cal. Jun 13, 2006), Document 185 Exhibit 2
Bond revoked for committing crimes while on pretrial release
Despite being caught running a Ponzi scheme by the SEC and being criminally charged for multiple frauds, the court found that Coberly continued to commit crimes while out on bond, stating that there was “probable cause to believe that defendant committed crime while on pretrial release”. Consequently, Coberly’s bond was revoked, and he was taken into custody pending trial.
After pleading guilty, Coberly served time in federal prison before being released in 2012:
US Bureau of Prisons Inmate Locator
Reeder and Coberly are Close Associates
LinkedIn profile of Robert Coberly
Coberly and his current wife worked for Reeder at UCR Group. In 2018, she was listed as a team member on the company’s website under the name Nicole Armstrong, which is her middle and maiden name:
UCR Group website, archived 2018-08-29
Later, in August 2019, Robert Coberly was added to the team page, appearing alongside Nicole Armstrong:
UCR Group website, archived 2019-08-26
Former employees confirmed that the two worked for Reeder at UCR Group and that Summer Coberly and Nicole Armstrong are the same person.
Reeder and Coberly are Connected to Prior Stock Manipulation Schemes
Reeder and Coberly are longtime associates, and they’ve been involved in multiple alleged fraudulent schemes together, including stock manipulation schemes in the early 2000s.
Capitol Silver Mines
Reeder and Coberly were named defendants in a lawsuit about fraud at Capitol Silver Mines. The court ruled in favor of the plaintiff on all counts:
The defendants, including Reeder and Coberly, were found jointly and severally liable for over $6M, to be paid to the company:
Senior Care Industries, Inc
The crew from the Capitol Silver Mines scheme was also involved in Senior Care Industries, where Coberly and Reeder were again central figures. Reeder was Chairman and CEO, while Coberly was CFO and a director:

Senior Care Industries, Inc., Form 10-QSB, filed 2001-05-14
Court records and SEC filings show that Reeder, along with his brother Charles, was involved in questionable real estate transactions with Senior Care Industries. For example, in May 2002, Charles sold the company a strip mall for $250,000 and 1.1M shares of the company. Later that same year, the company sold real estate, including the strip mall, back to Charles and Stephen Reeder, in exchange for a $500,000 promissory note. Months later, the company stated “Both notes are deemed uncollectible and were reduced to zero.”
According to a civil suit, after effectively stealing the properties from Senior Care Industries, the Reeder brothers transferred a loan to the strip mall property and then promptly defaulted on the loan. They each got $200,000 from the lender and stopped making payments a year after they reacquired the strip mall. These types of deals shine light on Reeder’s character and his history of fraud.
As for the stock fraud, Mervyn Phelan Jr and Sr ultimately went to prison for their involvement:
SEC Litigation Release No. 19582 / March 1, 2006
And in 2015, Phelan Sr. was again sentenced to prison, this time 5 years for defrauding investors out of $17.4M.
Slayton - Connected to Prior Stock Frauds and EMAT
The accountant James Slayton was also involved in these frauds. His name appeared in filings for Senior Care Industries and he was the auditor for Freedom Surf, a company that faked equipment valuations and whose stock price was manipulated by insiders. Slayton’s involvement in these schemes resulted in him losing his CPA license and he was barred from practicing as an accountant before the SEC.
As we showed earlier, Slayton is now a director of Springrock Management, a Reeder shell company that holds 96.8M shares of EMAT.
David Wilcox - Founder, Chairman, and Majority Shareholder
Wilcox’s recent legal troubles include domestic violence cases involving two different romantic partners, and a 2024 DUI in Idaho. He is currently on probation, is prohibited from consuming alcohol or drugs, and his driver’s license is suspended. Sources close to Wilcox describe him as a heavy drinker and we have evidence that he has continued to drink heavily despite being prohibited from consuming drugs or alcohol as a condition of his release in an ongoing criminal case. Wilcox’s behavior is a liability for the company and raises larger questions about his suitability to lead a multi-billion dollar public company.
Ongoing Criminal Case for Violating a Domestic Violence Protective Order
According to court records, Wilcox was arrested in November 2025 for violating a protective order related to domestic violence.

The criminal case is ongoing and is scheduled for a jury trial in December 2026.
Driving Under the Influence - Idaho, 2024
In December 2024, Wilcox was charged with DUI in Idaho:
As a result of the case, Wilcox served 2 days in jail, had his driver’s license suspended, and is on probation until July 2027. As a condition of his probation, Wilcox is prohibited from consuming alcohol or drugs and he must submit to random drug and alcohol testing.

Domestic Violence - Florida, 2022
In 2022, Wilcox was the defendant in another domestic violence case, this time in Florida:

The case was ultimately withdrawn by the alleged victim.
Conclusion
The problems at Evolution Metals go far beyond what’s covered in this report. There is simply too much to cover in a single report. We focused on what we believe to be the most damning evidence and the most important information for investors. This includes the management team conspiring to pay $2 million dollars to silence a whistleblower, the felony backgrounds of key insiders, and secret financial arrangements between insiders and convicted felons.
There is plenty of additional information that we have not included in this report and we encourage you to do your own research. The company’s financial statements are riddled with red flags and inconsistencies that warrant investigation. Given the scale of the problems at Evolution Metals, investors should carefully evaluate the risks before making any investment decisions.
Given the strong evidence of wrongdoing at Evolution Metals, we believe the company faces serious legal and regulatory risks, including SEC investigations, criminal investigations of insiders, and civil lawsuits from investors.
Legal Disclaimer
Affiliates of Capybara Research are short shares of Evolution Metals & Technologies Corp (NASDAQ: EMAT)
Our research reports are for informational purposes and express our opinions, formulated from publicly available information, field research, and our work as investigative journalists. We firmly believe that publishing our research and opinions is in the public interest and is protected speech. We are entitled to our opinions and to express and share our opinions in a public forum.
Capybara Research is not a registered investment advisor. By accessing our reports, you acknowledge that you are responsible for your investment decisions and you bear full responsibility to do your own independent research and due diligence. This website and its contents are not to be construed as an offer, solicitation, or recommendation for any investment products or strategies. Any investment examples are for educational purposes only and do not guarantee future performance.
We strive for accuracy in our reports, however the information is provided "as is", without any express or implied warranty. All expressions of opinion are subject to change without notice, and we do not commit to updating our reports or publishing supplementary information. Capybara Research, its affiliates, and its associated entities are in no way liable for any direct or indirect trading losses caused by actions taken based in any part on information in this report.
As of the publication date of this report, Capybara Research and its related parties including but not limited to any members, partners, affiliates, employees, and consultants (Capybara) have a financial interest in the securities discussed in this report, including long and/or short positions in shares, debt, options, or other derivative instruments. If our reporting leads to changes in the prices of financial instruments, we may realize significant financial gains. Our affiliates actively manage their positions and after publication of our report may be long, short, or neutral at any time thereafter regardless of the views expressed in our report. You should assume that all positions held by Capybara affiliates will be closed immediately after publication. Capybara will not provide updates on its financial positioning after publication.
